The Aftermath Report™
Commentary by Dr. T. McGuinnessDeadlyStorms.com & TropicalStorms.usSeptember 5, 2005
We are all stunned by the impact of Katrina on the Gulf States, especially on New Orleans. Our hearts go out to the countless lives lost, and their families, and all the survivors of this storm. As a survivor of 9 hurricanes, including Andrew, I do understand.
However, let me take a moment to put things in perspective. I am also mad as hell!
As a people, we have seen the worst of our citizens and local government in the Aftermath of this storm! We all have seem misery in past storms, and people pulled together to get through. Certainly many did with this storm also, but countless thugs used it as their personal holiday from the law. Make no mistake, we will remember, and one by one find those responsible.
Now let's talk about responsibility. Each person who remained in New Orleans, who was physically able to evacuate, and didn't, is PERSONALLY responsible for themselves and risked their own lives. There is plenty of blame to pass around, but start with yourself - collectively you blew it! Next time, you won't - we live and learn. I did! I stayed in my home during Hurricane Andrew with my family. Fortunately, we were far enough inland not to face the risk of Storm Surge. But, as we now know, Andrew was far worse than predicted, just like Katrina. I personally will never stay in the face of a Cat 4 or higher storm again.
So who is to blame for the unbelievable catastrophe in New Orleans? THE CITY OF NEW ORLEANS AND ITS MAYOR! The City government IS responsible for its citizens. It was responsible for knowing and evacuating its hospitals. nursing homes, and going street by street to get the people out. It knew, better than any the risks that it faced. Louisiana is a poor state compared to most others, and its state government leaves much to be desired, but the City is the center of economic growth for the state. It should have done far better! Its performance is nothing but criminal.
Clearly, the City is a failure. It is directly responsible for the deaths of thousands of its citizens. It is my sincere hope that its Mayor will face appropriate State & Federal sanctions (criminal) for this tragedy. Maybe there is a chance to clean house in one of the most corrupt cities in America. Maybe it is time to pull the cities charter and unincorporate it. Turn the Bourbon Street area into a National Park, and the rest of the city administered by a new City or the State.
In the aftermath of the storm, we have witnessed inefficiency to be sure, but no matter how many "war games" or plans are made, the reality is always different. It takes time to move. Frankly, I applaud the actions of the Federal Government overall, and President Bush specifically. Though, regrettably the current director of FEMA is proving to be less than competent in his job, they are generally doing the right things. When Andrew hit, then as now, it took the country by surprise, and it took five full days to marshal response in force. I would remind all that it only took four days with New Orleans. Granted it was not perfect, and was held back by state AND local governments, but it was there. We live and learn.
With most Hurricanes, they are relatively small geographically - Andrew devastated two counties in Florida, and one in Louisiana. Katrina devastated THREE STATES! Let's keep things in perspective. The response had nothing to do with our War on Terror, Iraq, or anything else, except the logistics to turning on the largest relief operation in our country's history.
This is the largest hit in our country's history, so let's drop all of the racial tactics. It debases us all. Let's be honest enough to recognize the stupidity of those that voluntarily remained, and faced the truth of Katrina, and the incompetence of the local government that failed to protect its citizens. Point your ire where it is deserved, while you keep your eyes on the horizon - this storms season is barely half over!
TMc